Will Trumps’ Record-Setting Execution Spree Create Biden’s “Dukakis Moment?”

Image for post
Image for post
Abraham Bonowitz is Director of Death Penalty Action. Photo by Jeremy Hogan.

Even without Tuesday’s execution of William LeCroy, the Trump Administration had already racked up more executions in ten weeks than any president since the 1950's.

With today’s (9/24/2020) execution of Christopher Vialva, there will be several additional noteworthy facts about this federal execution spree:

No other federal executions are currently scheduled, but the original intention of these executions has been achieved. The president’s reelection campaign scripted these executions perfectly as part of their “law and order” messaging.

Image for post
Image for post
Screen-shot of an e-mail sent by the Trump campaign on July 15, 2020.

In fact, immediately following the first federal execution in 17 years, the Trump campaign issued an e-mail touting the achievement and challenging Joe Biden to explain why he would not execute an “evil killer” such as Daniel Lee. The e-mail celebrates achieving “total justice” for the murder victims when, in that case, the victim’s family pleaded with the President to not carry out the execution and instead commute the sentence to life without parole.

Two of the executions took place during the week of the Republican National Convention. There was no mention of these executions during the convention, but surely it was on the tip of the president’s tongue. President Trumps’ patient restraint has been remarkable.

However, we won’t have to wait much longer. Next week is the first live presidential debate, when we may see President Trump pull this out of his pocket as a way to distinguish himself from Joe Biden and Kamala Harris.

“I’ve executed seven killers,” Trump will say. “You Democrats are weak on crime. Your platform calls for abolishing executions. Why should we let such evil killers live?”

Seven prisoners will have been killed to create this practically unavoidable bear trap. Will Biden step in it, or skirt it? It will be tricky to address this challenge without giving the Trump campaign exactly the sound bite all of these executions are designed to produce. Will this be Joe Biden’s “Dukakis moment,” or is he ready to effectively pivot, to be pro-victim and tough on crime while also clearly and concisely explaining why the death penalty fails us as a public policy and a crime-fighting tool?

For the younger set, in the 1988 presidential race, Massachussetts Governor Michael Dukakis gave a matter-of-fact response of opposition to the death penalty when he was challenged in a live debate by George H.W. Bush to explain how he (Dukakis) would react if his wife were to be murdered. This created an opening that the Bush campaign exploited so effectively that Dukakis was never able to recover.

Times were different then, and we know so much more now then we did then about how the death penalty fails us as a public policy. Public opinion on the matter has shifted significantly, and many conservatives, republicans, and other people in the “pro-life” community now reject capital punishment.

Image for post
Image for post
https://joebiden.com/justice/# Screenshot from September 24, 2020

Joe Biden, long a champion of the death penalty, surprised everyone when his presidential campaign announced a criminal justice policy that does not support capital punishment. His stated policy points to the concern of wrongful convictions, a concern so real that his web page needs to update the numbers. It says “Over 160 individuals” have been exonerated and released from death row, but as of last week that number is now 172. That number will only grow.

Today is the seventh scheduled federal execution under the Trump administration. So far, every one of these executions have been carried out, despite the pandemic and in some cases, with questionable legal shenanigans.

The day President Trump took office there were at least 11 federal death row prisoners who had exhausted their appeals and were ready for an execution date. Why did the Trump team wait 27 months to announce execution dates? Simply put, Team Trump wanted to exploit the hot-button issue of the death penalty to help with the Trump reelection effort. The dates were originally set for December and January, right at the beginning of the primary and caucus season for Democrats. Various legal challenges stayed those dates, but the legal challenge to questions regarding the method of execution was dismissed by April, conveniently allowing dates to be re-set so as to play perfectly into the convention and debate schedule. Here we go.

Popcorn, anyone?

Pivot Points on the Death Penalty:

Image for post
Image for post
https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/facts-and-research/dpic-reports/in-depth/enduring-injustice-the-persistence-of-racial-discrimination-in-the-u-s-death-penalty#lynchings-v-executions-interactive-visualization

What is Death Penalty Action doing about it?

Death Penalty Action has built a coalition of nearly 200 organizations so far, calling on Congress to address this issue. The specific requests are:

Sign the petition here.

Add your group to the organizational sign-on letter here.

Donate to support this work here.

Visit this page for more that you can do to help stop federal executions.

Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Set here to create the display image

Written by

Death Penalty Action provides high visibility resources, leadership and support in order to stop executions.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store